An ILR Buffalo Co-Lab InitiativeWage Atlas

Updates

Explainer

Why the First Pillar Is Now Anti-Oppression

In June 2020, when High Road Policy (HRP) first set out to define the high road, we described the means of getting there with four pillars: anti-racist, reparative, cooperative, and prefigurative. From here on, the first of those pillars has a new name – namely, anti-oppression.

Nothing else in the framework moves. The other three pillars stay as they were, as do the three ends of the high road (shared prosperity, environmental sustainability, and participatory democracy), which come from the work of Joel Rogers, and the three strategies for change (Prefigure, Disrupt, and Capture).

The new name does two jobs. First, it says plainly what our 2020 text already meant – namely, that the high road opposes every system through which some people exploit, sideline, silence, or harm others. That means racism, which sits at the center of the political economy of the United States (U.S.), and it also means sexism, ableism, homophobia and transphobia, class domination, and the domination of the living world. Next, the new name ties the pillar to Paulo Freire, whose Pedagogy of the Oppressed supplies what the old wording lacked: (1) an account of how oppression keeps itself going through the ways in which people learn to see the world; and (2) an account of how people undo it together, through dialogue, critical consciousness, and praxis.

With both of those jobs in mind, we propose a definition of the pillar in two parts. To be anti-oppressive is:

(1) to actively tear down, with the intent to fully eradicate, the structures through which some people exploit, marginalize, disempower, culturally dominate, or do violence to others; and (2) to do that work dialogically – that is, with the people most affected as co-authors of the change, rather than as its recipients.

Whereas the first part keeps the force of the 2020 wording, the second part is new, and it is the part that comes from Freire. In other words, it makes how change is pursued a test of whether that change is anti-oppressive at all.

Below, we explain where the pillar came from, why we broadened it, what Freire adds to it, and what does (and does not) change as a result.

Where the pillar came from

The pillar first appeared in two places in 2020: (1) the June special edition of the HRP memo series, Defining and Advancing High Road Policy; and (2) “Envisioning a High Road for the 21st Century,” or “High Road-21” for short, which was published in Solutions that fall. The special edition defined anti-racism as “actively tearing down, with the intent to fully eradicate, the sources of racial, social, economic, environmental, and political inequity and injustice that presently transcend all scales of our shared society.” High Road-21 then grounded the pillar in Ibram X. Kendi’s How to Be an Antiracist. Following Kendi, a policy or institution is anti-racist if it “produces or sustains racial equity between racial groups,” and there is “no such thing as a nonracist or race-neutral policy.”

Crucially, though, the 2020 text already reached beyond race. The Solutions article described its vision of the high road as “anti-racist, anti-sexist, anti-misogynist, anti-ableist, anti-homophobic, anti-transphobic, anti-classist, and opposed to all other forms of prejudice and discrimination.” Its pull quote read: “Taking the High Road requires a commitment to dismantling the vast, intersecting sources of oppression in society.” Along these lines, the High Road Policy Questionnaire that we use in eCornell’s Equitable Community Change certificate asks, under the heading Anti-Racist, whether a proposal would eliminate sources of inequity “particularly with respect to race, ethnicity, gender, ability, sexual orientation, or social class.” What is more, the About page of this relaunched site already says anti-oppressive.

In other words, the label was narrower than what it held. That gap caused two problems:

  1. Readers took the pillar to be about race alone. Other forms of domination came across as add-ons, when the text in fact treated all of them as one family of problems.
  2. Kendi’s test judges outcomes, not process. While it is a strong test of whether a policy narrows or widens a gap, it says little about who decides, how people come to see the gap in the first place, or whether the people who are harmed have any say in the remedy. Put differently, a policy can pass the outcome test while being designed for people rather than with them – which is the move that Freire calls false generosity.

Why broaden? Oppression is the shared mechanism

The course on policy in the Equitable Community Change certificate already gives us a working definition. Following Erik Olin Wright and Joel Rogers, a social injustice is an inequality that is both unfair and a product of our institutions, such that it could be corrected by changing those institutions. In the words of the course: “This combination of inequality, injustice, and uneven power relations is what is often meant by oppression.” Oppression, then, is injustice that power keeps in place, and that is exactly what the high road framework is built to analyze. After all, policies are rules, rules are rarely neutral, and “rules are protected by power.”

Naming the mechanism, rather than just one of its forms, has three advantages.

First, it covers the whole family. Iris Marion Young’s “five faces of oppression” offer a usable checklist, and each face already shows up in HRP’s own work:

  • Exploitation. The fruits of some people’s labor flow steadily to others. The Wage Atlas, for instance, shows that nearly half of New York workers earn less than a living wage for their household.
  • Marginalization. Whole groups are pushed out of useful participation in social life. Consider Buffalo’s East Side “dead zone,” which is a persistent cluster of the lowest home sales inside formerly redlined neighborhoods.
  • Powerlessness. People take orders and rarely give them, and they have little say over the decisions that govern them. Here, think of the lower rungs of Arnstein’s ladder of citizen participation, the narrow “allowable remedies” that are left to residents, and the turnout gap between renters and homeowners.
  • Cultural imperialism. One group’s experience is treated as the norm, while others are made invisible or stereotyped. “Bootstrap” stories and the organization of consent – what the iceberg model calls invisible power – are cases in point.
  • Violence. People face random or systematic attacks, along with the standing threat of them. Evictions carried out by the state and police killings both belong here.

Next, it matches how people are actually harmed. In 1977, the Combahee River Collective wrote that “the major systems of oppression are interlocking,” and it called for “integrated analysis and practice.” Kimberlé Crenshaw’s work on intersectionality later showed that harms at the crossing of race and gender disappear from view when each axis is analyzed alone. Consider that a Black woman who works as a home health aide on Buffalo’s East Side meets exploitation, marginalization, and powerlessness all at once. A pillar that is named for one axis invites precisely the single-axis analysis that misses her.

Finally, it is the ground for solidarity. The collective action course in the certificate devotes part of its first module to “divide and conquer” – that is, the strategy of keeping people who share a condition from seeing that condition as shared. By contrast, a pillar that names oppression as such gives people on different sides of those dividing lines a common object to organize against. That is how a township that voted for Donald Trump by roughly seventy points came to pass a robust community rights law.

Why Freire

Freire is already part of the Equitable Community Change certificate. Chapter 4 of Pedagogy of the Oppressed is a reading in the collective action course, the research course defines praxis with him, and one of the certificate’s tracks is named Critical Consciousness. Making him the anchor of the first pillar brings six ideas into the framework.

1. Oppression is a relationship, and its harm is dehumanization. In Freire’s words: “Any situation in which ‘A’ objectively exploits ‘B’ or hinders his and her pursuit of self-affirmation as a responsible person is one of oppression” (p. 55). In other words, the measure is not only who has more, but also who is allowed to act as a full subject in their own life.

2. Oppression lives inside people as well as around them. The oppressed become “hosts” of the oppressor (p. 48), and they absorb the oppressor’s view of them until they are “convinced of their own unfitness” (p. 63). This is what the certificate calls invisible power, and what the collective action course calls humiliation and self-blame. It is also where the Commoning Consciousness work on norms, systems, and the tended commons joins the high road: oppression is carried in a partly shared consciousness, in what people expect of themselves and in what they see others doing.

3. How we teach and decide can itself oppress. In what Freire calls the “banking” model of education, “knowledge is a gift bestowed by those who consider themselves knowledgeable upon those whom they consider to know nothing” (p. 72). The adapted version of Arnstein’s ladder that we use in high road teaching has a rung for exactly this, called Educating, where residents are treated as “passive receivers of information and not active participants.” By contrast, Freire’s alternative is problem-posing education, in which people name their own situation and study it together.

4. Change comes through praxis. Freire defines praxis as “reflection and action upon the world in order to transform it” (p. 51). That is the loop of participatory action research (look, think, act), and it is also the loop of the dual power strategy (build, test, reflect, rebuild).

5. Freire offers a theory of how domination works, and of how liberation organizes. Chapter 4 sets four features of antidialogical action against four features of dialogical action. Read beside the high road framework, the former are what hold the low road in place, whereas the latter are what build the high road. (This pairing is our reading, not Freire’s.)

  • Conquest, which turns people into objects, is answered by cooperation, in which “Subjects meet in cooperation in order to transform the world.” In our framework, this is the cooperative pillar.
  • Divide and rule is answered by unity for liberation. In our framework, this is solidarity, or base-building across dividing lines.
  • Manipulation, which Freire describes as an “unauthentic type of ‘organization’” from above, is answered by organization of and by the people. In our framework, this is organizing, as opposed to advocacy or mobilizing alone.
  • Cultural invasion is answered by cultural synthesis. In our framework, this is prefiguration – alternatives that are built with communities, not delivered to them.

6. Freire warns that the oppressed can become oppressors. In the first stage of a struggle, the oppressed “tend themselves to become oppressors, or ‘sub-oppressors’” (p. 45), because the only model of power that they have seen is power over others. The task, by contrast, is “to liberate themselves and their oppressors as well” (p. 44). For the high road, this is the most important caution in the book. Capturing an institution without changing how it works just puts new people in the old seats.

One more passage ties the pillar to the property questions that the rest of the framework raises. The oppressor consciousness, Freire writes, turns “the earth, property, production, the creations of people, people themselves, time” into objects at its disposal; “for them, to be is to have” (p. 58). The difference between owning in order to use and owning in order to dominate is where anti-oppression meets the reparative pillar, along with the distinction between possessions and property.

What does not change

Race stays named, and it stays central. In the U.S., racism is not one oppression among many that just happens to appear in the data. Rather, it is braided through the others – which is what Cedric Robinson meant by racial capitalism – and HRP’s own findings keep showing as much. In Buffalo, for instance, the block groups that the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation graded C or D in the 1930s still carry more than four times the average disadvantage of the areas that it graded A (see Erasing Red Lines). Across the U.S., meanwhile, a student in a district that serves mostly students of color receives, on average, $2,226 less in state and local funding than a student in a mostly white district, and in New York, the gap between low-income districts of color and low-income white districts is $4,094 per student (EdBuild, 2019). The upshot is that an anti-oppression pillar that let race drop out of view would fail its own test.

The outcome test stays. Kendi’s central claim – that no policy is neutral – carries over whole, and it gets wider: every policy produces or sustains either oppression or its undoing, along every axis that it touches. Likewise, the questionnaire keeps asking whether a proposal closes gaps.

We guard against dilution. Broad words can become empty ones – that is, an institution can declare itself “anti-oppressive” and change nothing, in much the same way that “diversity” statements often do. With that in mind, we guard against that outcome with two habits: (1) every use of the pillar should name which face of oppression is at stake, and who bears it; and (2) in U.S. settings, every analysis should ask how race runs through the case – even when the case is framed in terms of class, gender, disability, or place.

What changes in practice

The questionnaire’s first row becomes three. Whereas the High Road Policy Questionnaire now asks one question under Anti-Racist, we propose three under Anti-Oppressive, with one each for outcome, power, and process:

  1. Outcome. Would this proposal eliminate one or more existing sources of inequity between communities or groups, particularly with respect to race, ethnicity, gender and gender identity, ability, sexual orientation, citizenship, or social class? A “yes” means that a gap closes, and that the analysis says which gap and for whom.
  2. Power. Would it move decision-making power toward the people most affected, rather than only delivering benefits to them? A “yes” means a step up the participation ladder, to partnership, delegated power, or resident control.
  3. Process. Did the people most affected help to name the problem and shape the remedy? A “yes” means dialogue, not banking – that is, the proposal came out of organizing, a community visioning process, or participatory research.

The other five questions stay as they are, so the tool grows from six questions to eight.

Capture gets a check. Freire’s warning about sub-oppressors becomes a standing question for every Capture campaign: when we win this institution, what will change about how it works, and not only who runs it? In practice, that means rules that let members recall leaders, open books, rotating roles, and decisions that are made by the people whom the institution serves. After all, a captured institution that keeps its old shape will select for the old behavior in its new occupants.

Participation is judged by the rung. Consultation and “educating” are not participation. HRP’s own projects, including our data tools, should aim for partnership or higher, and we should say so honestly when they fall short.

Research is done with people, not on them. The participatory action research methods that we already teach in the certificate become the default for HRP studies, wherever the people affected can be organized into the work.

The record stays as published. The 2020 special edition, High Road-21, and our earlier briefs keep their original wording, and the special edition’s page on this site now links to this post. By contrast, the questionnaire, the checklist, and the course materials take the new wording at their next revision.

How the first pillar fits with the others

The four pillars were always meant to hold each other up, and the new first pillar strengthens each of the other three.

  • Reparative. Oppression leaves debts (wealth gaps, devalued neighborhoods, and poisoned land), and repair is what anti-oppression owes once the harm is named. Freire’s “to be is to have” points at the property form of that debt, which is why the reparative pillar will pay close attention to the difference between possessions that people use and property that is held to dominate.
  • Cooperative. Freire’s first feature of dialogical action is cooperation among equals. Cooperation does not survive inside a group where some members can take power over the rest, and anti-oppression is what keeps cooperation from being captured by its strongest members.
  • Prefigurative. Dialogical action is prefigurative by nature – that is, meetings that are run by rounds and consent, research that is done with residents, and institutions that are governed by their members already practice the relations that they are fighting for.

Finally, the pillar is the hinge of a larger project. A book now in preparation joins the high road framework to scholarship on the commons and depth psychology. Its argument is that the same fundamental problem of social life – the pull of narrow advantage against the common good – plays out in two places at once: (1) in the material world of power and property; and (2) in the shared world of expectation and attention. Freire is the bridge between them, in that he shows how domination outside becomes domination inside, and how people undo both together.

Sources

Page numbers for Freire refer to the edition listed here.

  • Arnstein, Sherry R. “A Ladder of Citizen Participation.” Journal of the American Institute of Planners 35, no. 4 (1969): 216–24.
  • Combahee River Collective. “The Combahee River Collective Statement” (1977). In How We Get Free: Black Feminism and the Combahee River Collective, edited by Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor. Chicago: Haymarket Books, 2017.
  • Crenshaw, Kimberlé. “Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics.” University of Chicago Legal Forum 1989, no. 1: 139–67.
  • Crenshaw, Kimberlé. “Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Color.” Stanford Law Review 43, no. 6 (1991): 1241–99.
  • EdBuild. $23 Billion. Jersey City, NJ: EdBuild, 2019.
  • Freire, Paulo. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. 30th anniversary ed. Translated by Myra Bergman Ramos. New York: Continuum, 2005.
  • Kendi, Ibram X. How to Be an Antiracist. New York: One World, 2019.
  • Robinson, Cedric J. Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition. London: Zed Press, 1983.
  • Weaver, Russell. Erasing Red Lines: Part 1, Geographies of Discrimination. Buffalo, NY: Cornell University ILR School, Buffalo Co-Lab, 2019.
  • Weaver, Russell. “Defining and Advancing High Road Policy: Concepts, Strategies, and Tactics.” High Road Policy 1, no. 2SE (June 2020).
  • Weaver, Russell. “Envisioning a High Road for the 21st Century.” Solutions (Fall 2020): 118–23.
  • Weaver, Russell. High Road Policy Questionnaire and High Road-21 Policy Checklist. eCornell Equitable Community Change certificate, ILR 544. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University, 2023.
  • Wright, Erik Olin, and Joel Rogers. American Society: How It Really Works. 2nd ed. New York: W. W. Norton, 2015.
  • Young, Iris Marion. Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1990. See chapter 2, “Five Faces of Oppression.”